Service recovery paradox: Is it worth achieving?

Service recovery paradox: Is it worth achieving?

James Glenn Gomez Published on November 8, 2017

excited delighted businessman in office hallway making phone call

Should your contact center aim for excellent customer service or a service recovery paradox?

As much as you strive to provide each of your consumers high quality customer support, it’s important to note that service failures will still occur at some point. It may stem from your call center’s strategies and procedures, or a failure in the technology or tools you’ve been using, or it may be caused by one errant agent. It happens. It’ll frustrate customers; that’s expected. So, you have to make it up to them and repair the affected customer relationship.
Sometimes, however, customers become even more satisfied when you attempt service recovery, compared to when they receive trouble-free service from you. This is what’s known as the service recovery paradox (SRP). It’s indeed a paradox, a novel idea being touted as a way to boost customer satisfaction to higher levels and improve brand perception. It shows that business and marketing opportunities abound, even in failure. But should your call center even aim for it or just deliver excellent, spotless customer service?

What affects the effectiveness of SRP?

Before delving into the issue, let’s take a closer look at SRP. Several studies have heralded its effectiveness since the early ’90s, starting with the research published by Michael McCollough and Sundar Bharadwaj in 1992. Using the term “recovery paradox”, the two marketing researchers theorized that businesses can achieve boosted customer satisfaction ratings when they recover from a service failure.
However, according to Magnini, et al. (2007), there are still variables that affect the overall effectiveness of SRP. These are the following.

1. How bad was the service failure?

frustrated office employee in glasses bears looking at laptop

Severe failures that often leaves the business relationship in an irreparable state will obviously render SRP close to impossible. On the other hand, apologies and proper compensation can be effective recovery measures for lesser service errors.

 

2. How often did your call center wrong the customer?

woman in brink of tears

Customers have small patience when it comes to a business relationship. According to customer service expert Ruby Newell-Legner, it can take about 12 excellent customer service interactions to make up for one negative customer experience. That said, SRP becomes moot for contact centers who have repeat failures.

 

3. How long has the customer been with the company?

tired frustrated business executive in dark

The effectiveness of recovery efforts is also affected by the number of transactions the customer has had with the company. If the business relationship is fraught to begin with, SRP would be less possible as failure only decreases the customers’ confidence on your call center.

 

4. How likely would the service failure be prevented?

disappointed office worker staring at smartphone

Was the mistake beyond your control or could it have been prevented? Customers are more likely to forgive and continue to do business with you if the said disaster was caused by unforseen circumstances, such as service outages. Customers aren’t as forgiving, however, if companies have even a smidge of control over what happened.

 

5. Would the mistake ever reoccur?

disappointed business woman holding smartphone tablet

Future inconveniences can definitely affect any service recovery efforts. You’ve already inconvenienced your customers, what’s the likelihood of it happening again? If the issue’s likely to occur again, the efforts will be for naught.

 

Should you then focus on service recovery efforts instead?

delighted excited business team in office looking pointing laptop

Michel and Coughlan (2009) disputed the idea that all efforts should be focused on SRP. In their study, they stated that an excellent recovery effort indeed improves the customer satisfaction rating better than a satisfactory, error-free service. But, they also found out that when it comes to customer satisfaction, an excellent customer service effort trumps SRP.
Another reason for your company not to focus on recovery efforts is if customers are taking advantage of your agents’ kindness. And while it’s important to make up for mistakes, you shouldn’t let your call center be preyed upon by opportunistic customers aiming to exploit a company’s compensation policies. Add to the fact that SRP can be very expensive to pull off repeatedly, you should be wary on who to compensate.
Simply put, service recovery paradox shouldn’t be used as an excuse for bad customer service. Your Call center should always strive to deliver quality customer support and ensuring memorable customer experiences. Making your customer support strategies proactive will also help your call center anticipate possible customer concerns and make solutions readily available. But when exigencies occur, your service recovery efforts should neither be overdone nor half-baked.

Leave a Reply

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK
Open Access BPO
Open Access BPO2 days ago
Multilingual #CallCenter Open Access BPO has strategic locations that support high-end infrastructure, redundant resources and a network of dedicated professionals that will help businesses address the unique needs of their target market.

Learn more about our global delivery sites here: https://zcu.io/aLAm

#WeSpeakYourLanguage
Open Access BPO
Open Access BPO4 days ago
Call centers cannot afford data loss. However, circumstances like hardware glitches, #cyber attacks, and natural disasters can lead to this.

How do you protect the lifeline of your #CallCenter in such cases? Find out in this blog: https://zcu.io/bjPx

#WeSpeakYourLanguage
Open Access BPO
Open Access BPO6 days ago
Your customer service defines your business. The first step to ensuring that you do the right thing is to adapt the language that helps you deliver excellent #CustomerSupport: https://zcu.io/JRI2

#WeSpeakYourLanguage #CustServ #CallCenter
Open Access BPO
Open Access BPO1 week ago
Effective communication goes beyond simply using the same language as your consumers. That is why companies outsource their #multilingual #CallCenter: to have the ability to provide the kind of support consumers understand.

Read more on adapting the right language to build customer rapport: https://zcu.io/IMsh

#WeSpeakYourLanguage #CustomerService
Open Access BPO
Open Access BPO1 week ago
Unsure of how to improve customer relationships? Check out this overview of generational preferences to understand what influences your customers' decisions and how to meet their needs: https://zcu.io/AygQ

#WeSpeakYourLanguage #CustServ #CustomerSupport
Open Access BPO
Open Access BPO2 weeks ago
Unexpected interruptions in your #CallCenter operations can cost customers' trust and your brand's reputation. Discover how smart #offshore redundancy can mitigate these threats: https://zcu.io/8Vtz

#WeSpeakYourLanguage